Whether LIMITATION ACT APPLICABLE ON INSOLVENCY & BANKRUPTCY CODE, 2016
Whether
LIMITATION ACT APPLICABLE ON INSOLVENCY & BANKRUPTCY CODE, 2016
Short Summary:
In this flash tabloid, the writer initiates by speak of
the provisions of Insolvency & Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (hereafter referred as
“IBC”) in relation to Applicability of Limitation Act on IBC,2016.
The main drive of
the broadsheet, on the other hand, is upon the “Whether provisions of
Limitation Act applicable on Private Limited Companies ?”
This is article no. 288 of the series of editorials written by the author
on corporate laws
{Including Companies
Act, 2013, SEBI, RBI Regulations, IBC, LLP Act, 2008 etc.}.
Introduction:
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (the, “Code”) is a
crucial legislation passed by the Parliament which has the potential to be a
game changer in the insolvency and bankruptcy regime in India.
Since
this Code came into existence, all the professionals / Corporate has several questions
in mind, one of them about the “Applicability of the provisions of Limitation
act on the Code/ Whether application u/s 9 or 7 is time barred” for an example;
if any payment is pending older than 3 year or any loan is not repaid by the
corporate debtor which is older than 3 year. Whether Operational Creditor /
Financial creditor can file application under IBC, 2016. Many cases
filed before many benches of the NCLT which falls under the provisions of
Limitation.
Provision of Limitation Act:
Article
137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 is as follow:
Description of
Application |
Period of Limitation
|
Time from which
period begins to run
|
Any
other application for which no period of limitation is provided elsewhere in
this division.
|
Three Years
|
When the right to apply accrues
|
CASE DETAILS:
For
very first time, the issue on applicability of Limitation Act, 1963 to the
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code was considered by NCLAT in the matter of Neelkanth Township and Construction Pvt. Ltd. vs. Urban Infrastructure Trustee Ltd. and
it was held that the provisions of the Limitation Act, 1963 would not apply to
the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
A. Factual Background:
I.
an appeal filed by a corporate debtor
(Neelkanth Township & Construction Pvt. Ltd.) against the order of the
National Company Law Tribunal (“NCLT”) allowing commencement of insolvency
proceedings on the action of the financial creditor (Urban Infrastructure
Trustees Ltd.)
II.
The financial creditor had subscribed to optionally
convertible debentures (“OCDs”) issued by the corporate debtor. OCDs carried
nil or 1% p.a. interest rate and matured in years 2011, 2012 and 2013.
III.
The order of the NCLT was challenged by the
corporate debtor, on many grounds, one of the grounds was :
v Given that the debentures matured in years
2011, 2012 and 2013, the petition for initiation of corporate insolvency
resolution process filed in year 2017 is time barred.
IV.
The Learned Counsel for the Appellant contended
that the claim of Respondent is completed time barred as the Debenture
Certificates were due for redemption as far back as in the years 2011, 2012 and
2013 respectively; consequently, the application filed in the year 2017 is
hopelessly time barred.
Findings of the NCLAT Bench:
The NCLAT held that that in the absence of any provision in IBC, the
Limitation Act, 1963 would not be
applicable to initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process. The NCLAT
further observed:
“If there is a debt which includes interest and there is default of
debt and having continuous course of action, the argument that the claim of
money by Respondent is barred by Limitation cannot be accepted.”
This suggests that NCLAT treated the cause of action arising from non-payment of debt which includes
interest as a continuing one. Thereby holding that limitation period could not
have expired.
There is nothing on the record that Limitation Act, 2013 is applicable
to I&B Code. Learned Counsel for the appellant also failed to lay hand on
any of the provision of I&B Code to suggest that the Law of Limitation Act,
1963 is applicable.
The I&B Code, 2016 is not an Act for recovery of money claim, it
relates to initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process. If there
is a debt which includes interest and there is default of debt and having
continuous course of action, the argument that the claim of money by Respondent
is barred by Limitation cannot be accepted.”
In the above Judgment NCLAT mentioned that “Cause of action arising from non-payment of debt which includes interest as a continuing one, therefore, limitation period could not have expired.
But still one question arises if debt which doesn’t include
interest weather Limitation Period applies on such debt or not?
CASE DETAILS:
Case
Name
|
Black
Pearl Hotels Pvt Ltd. V/s Planet M Retail Ltd.
|
Operational
Creditor (Petitioner)
|
Black
Pearl Hotels Pvt Ltd
|
Corporate
Debtor
(Respondent)
|
Planet M Retail
Ltd
|
Bench
Name
|
NATIONAL
COMPANY LAW APPEALAT TRIBUNAL
|
Order
No.
|
C.P.
No.464/I&BP/NCLT/MAH/2017
|
Date
|
October
17, 2017
|
B. Factual Background:
I.
The
appellant who claimed to be OC, engage in operation a retail store in a
building, entered into a business conduct agreement with CD. The CD continued
to pay Rs. 7 Lakh per month from April, 201 to Sep 2011. Thereafter, since
October, 2011 the CD failed to pay the conducting fee and, therefore, the OC
terminated the business conduct agreement.
II.
The
OC issued the notice u/s 8 of IBC to CD. In reply CD denied the claim on the
ground that OC has not performed its duty in terms of agreement.
III.
After
waiting for 10 days oc file the case before Mumbai Bench of NCLT.
IV.
The
adjudicating authority by impugned order dated 4th May, 2017
dismissed the application u/s 9 on one of the grounds that the application was
barred by Limitation.
V.
NCLT
states that, it is to be noted that after the last payment September, 2011,
neither there was an acknowledgement of liability nor any payment by the
corporate debtor. In this claim the whole debit as claimed by the Financial
Creditor is time barred.
Question Arise:
VI.
Whether the application preferred by appellant
– Operational Creditor is barred by Limitation?
Findings of the NCLAT Bench:
The NCLAT ruled that even if it is
accepted that the Limitation Act, 1963 is applicable for initiation of Corporate
Insolvency Resolution Process, in such case Article 137 of the Limitation Act,
1963 will be applicable where the period of limitation is three years and
it begins when the right to apply accrues.
NCLAT in its order states that “Insolvency
and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 has come into force with effect from 1stDecember,
2016. Therefore, the right to apply under I&B Code accrues only on or after
1st December, 2016 and not before the said date (1st December, 2016).
As the right to apply under section 9 of I&B Code accrued to appellant
since 1stDecember, 2016, the application filed much prior to three years, the
said application cannot be held to be Barred by limitation.”
CONCLUSION:
In effect, the NCLAT has held that
debts which were otherwise not recoverable due to being time barred, can now be
basis for initiating insolvency proceedings. This is a stark change from the
earlier position and paves way for initiation of multiple insolvency
proceedings on debts which could earlier not be recovered.
Thanks for your tip to find a bankruptcy lawyer by looking at options online. I like how you said that you should hire the one who is experienced and can help you have success. My friend is considering bankruptcy attorneys who are experienced and help him get a lot for what he is spending.
ReplyDeleteAffordable bankruptcy lawyer
Great share!
ReplyDeleteI love this bucket list and you know you're right. sand blasting machine manufacturer. We all have the same amount of hours in a day so put them to good use. We all have to start somewhere and your plan is perfect. I understand the way of the attractive to the customer with the products sand blasting machine.
Sand blasting machines like shot blasting machine, sand blasting machine, and grit blasting machines, Wood Working Machinery Dust Extraction unit, Abrasive Blasting Media and various others. Keep it works and share with us your latest information. My time will come but I know I'm on the right path.
They are similar to small communities that you own - check them out if you haven't already. It's all got a lot better than before!t. Value that list of thousands but I'll get there.
Thanks for sharing. Have a nice week ahead.
Visit at : www.gritblast.co.in
Also check
portable shot blasting machine
portable sand blasting machine
sand blasting cabinet
grit blasting cabinet
shot blasting cabinet
Regards,
Ankit Manawat.